True. But there was a reason why so many people just left at the beginning of the fight. Even we had smart gunners most broadsides got eating by waves. We saw a lot of demasting while people tend to aim higher. If memory serve me well most people didnt liked it. Dont get me wrong i would be the first to try out dumb gunners but not sure if majority would like it, like patch 10.x which was in my opinion an awesome time ;-)