madmatg

I had the same problem

Hmm interesting

@BCH what difficulty level are you playing on? I have not been able to take the stone bridge on any of my tries and usually go up to the ford

@BCHI forget are Buell's reinforcements the ones that come during the hornets nest phase? If so I did, if there are other reinforcements that show up in the final phase at pitts landing then no. @pandakraut - Only had one corps fighting here, that's probably my problem, I was buffing up training thinking for the long term but I guess I need to be spending points on AM and econ so I can afford to field more men. The 1-2 cav units sound good also I just couldn't figure out how to fit them in my only corps. With 2 corps should be easier.

(I know this is nothing different from what people have been saying but just figured I'd post it) This was my second try at shiloh, both times had similar sizes of both sizes of the battle. I really felt good with the slow retreat but eventually a lack of supplies crippled the arty to where they couldn't repel the charges and then I was done for. The units of reinforcements that come at hornets nest were great but definitely needed at least one more group of reinforcements or at an extra supply truck to come up to resupply the arty. Finally lost at 2 hours left.

One thing that drives me crazy is the lack of a topo map as it's difficult to actually figure out high and low places, any chance that could be modded onto the map?

Just now hitting Shiloh and I concur, it is very difficult! d:

On Washington on the south map far east side: as my howitzers marched behind a unit of infantry they walked into a batch of trees to setup but then acted like they were in melee with the unit in the far southeast fortifications and were quickly killed. I never had any arty that far southeast in vanilla so I'm not sure whether this is a vanilla bug or not, I suspect it is.

I'm up to Washington now on MG and one thing I've noticed is that it seems like I have avoided having skirmishers in my armies as the enemy armory has progressed. I've found I'd rather have larger scaled infantry because while I'm fielding my regular skirmishers to be my eyes and ears they seem to be scaling to match that with skirmishers that are equipped with spencers and JF sniper rifles lol. Having 4-5 units of enemy 3*skirmishers with excellent rifles is pretty dreadful so I've pretty much just given up on skirmishers all together except a few SS units. Has anyone else noticed this?

I wasn't thining so much about having to keep those units but having them be how you receive recruits since there isn't a veteran and green pool you could get around that by having some veterans pop up that you could disband and then scatter throughout your other units. I understand though that that may not be what you are wanting to do just meant it as a way of dealing with the reinforcements work now

Thinking about doing Veterans, would it be possible to make recruiting veterans super expensive and then change the battle rewards to reduce recruits/gold and instead grant you multiple units of different veterancy levels already equipped with weapons of their veterancy level?

alrighty, got it installed, on to gettysburg

CSA MG on the last version before the surrendering arty units were fixed to start working. Fought the battle of Chancellorsville and won, then went to the Battle of Salem Church. After setting up my units I hit start battle and then it immediately went to "Defeat" screen. It shouldn't kill the campaign but it was definitely a bit 😫

I haven't had this bug in my CSA campaign

I've destroyed a number of arty brigades but haven't had any surrender yet, has anyone had this work?